Short-Term vs. Long-Term Rentals in Calgary: Which One Wins for ROI?

by Hasan Sharif

Short-Term vs. Long-Term Rentals in Calgary: Which One Wins for ROI?

Calgary’s rental market is booming, and if you’re thinking about investing, you’ve got two big options: short-term rentals (like Airbnb) or long-term rentals. Each has its ups and downs, so let’s break it down in a way that’s easy to understand.


1. Who Makes More Money?

  • Short-Term Rentals: These can bring in about $3,048 a month before expenses, which is more than the $2,800 a month that long-term rentals make. But because short-term rentals have extra costs (cleaning, furniture, etc.), their yearly profit is usually $13,144, while long-term rentals average $14,880 (Source: Airbtics).
  • Long-Term Rentals: They might earn less upfront, but they’re steady and don’t have as many extra costs.

Quick Take: Short-term makes more gross income, but long-term often keeps more money in your pocket.


2. How Often Will It Be Rented?

  • Short-Term Rentals: These are busy during tourist seasons (like summer in July) but quieter in off-peak months. Occupancy is about 78% on average (Source: Airbtics).
  • Long-Term Rentals: These are almost always rented, with rates between 90-100%. Leases keep them filled year-round (Source: HomeRiver Group).

Quick Take: Long-term rentals = steady. Short-term rentals = feast or famine.


3. How Much Work Does It Take?

  • Short-Term Rentals: You’ll need to clean up after guests, keep things maintained, and maybe hire help to manage bookings. Cleaning alone could cost you $4,800 a year, and if you hire someone to manage it all, they’ll take up to 25% of your income (Source: Arvy Realty).
  • Long-Term Rentals: These need way less day-to-day attention. Tenants handle their own utilities and only call you for major repairs. Management fees are usually just 8% of monthly rent (Source: Unison Realty Group).

Quick Take: Short-term = lots of hands-on work. Long-term = more chill.


4. What About Calgary’s Rules?

  • Short-Term Rentals: Calgary has strict rules—you’ll need a license (costing $172-$510 a year) and must follow safety and zoning regulations. If you’re in a condo, you’ll also need permission from the condo board (Source: City of Calgary).
  • Long-Term Rentals: These follow simple landlord-tenant laws, which don’t change much (Source: Residential Tenancies Act).

Quick Take: Long-term rentals are easier when it comes to rules.


5. Can You Get Financing?

  • Short-Term Rentals: Banks see these as risky, so they might ask for higher down payments (20-30%) and charge higher interest rates. Plus, you’ll need to spend extra to furnish the place (Source: Catalyst Condos).
  • Long-Term Rentals: Banks like these because they’re stable. You can get better interest rates, and rental income helps you qualify for loans (Source: CMHC Programs).

Quick Take: Long-term rentals are easier to finance.


6. What Could Go Wrong?

  • Short-Term Rentals: Income isn’t steady. Slow seasons hurt your wallet, and more guests mean more wear and tear on your property (Source: Masterhost).
  • Long-Term Rentals: The biggest worry here is a tenant not paying rent, but proper screening can reduce that risk (Source: WOWA.ca).

Quick Take: Short-term = unpredictable. Long-term = fewer surprises.


The Final Verdict

If you’re willing to put in the work and deal with the ups and downs, short-term rentals could give you higher income. But if you’re looking for something more stable and hands-off, long-term rentals are the way to go.

It all depends on your goals and how much time you’re ready to invest. Want help figuring it out? Reach out to a real estate advisor or property manager to get started!


Continue Your Journey

If you want to dive deeper into Calgary’s rental market, check out these related blogs: (COMING SOON)

Ready to explore more? Click on the links above or contact Hasan Sharif to get started today: 403-808.9705 

https://instagram.com/nasahctus

Hasan Sharif

I help buyers, sellers and property investors in Saskatoon and Calgary make informed decisions about their next move. Tell me what you have in mind and I’ll help you work through the options.

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message